
Prime Minister Tony Blair wants to lower the burden of proof in criminal cases, to allow conviction on the balance of probabilities, rather than beyond reasonable doubt, as at present. He says: "To require everything beyond reason able doubt in these cases is very difficult. I think people would accept that within certain categories of case, provided it's big enough, you don't take the normal burden ... It requires a different court process."
"Nonsense", says Dr Sean Gabb, Director of Communications for the Libertarian Alliance. "Crime is crime. Bringing in a different process for different crimes is a further nail in the coffin of liberty in this country. We were told a fortnight ago that "terrorist" offences might need a lower burden of proof - and by people who have been surrendering part of the United Kingdom into the hands of the IRA. Now we are told that this may apply to non-terrorist offences.
"The truth is, this government wants a police state and will use any excuse to get one. This legislation, if passed, would soon become the normal mode of trial of all offences. I predict it would be extended at first to politically correct crimes - I bet it would take a year for the proposals to be floated. Then it would be proposed for "paedophile" offences. Then to drinking and driving. Within a decade, we would all be subject to trial by kangaroo court.
"The Libertarian Alliance is utterly opposed to these proposed measures, and to any others that have been proposed or enacted so far. No one, however grave his alleged offence, should be subject to such breach of traditional rights. Even Mr Big has rights.
"The politicians and police in this country are out of control. These people will not stop until they are stopped."
Sean Gabb is available for media comment on 07956 472 199
He can be contacted for further comment on 07956 472 199 or by email at sean@libertarian.co.uk
Extended Contact Details:
The Libertarian Alliance is Britain’s most radical free market
and civil liberties policy institute. It has published over 700
articles, pamphlets and books in support of freedom and against
statism in all its forms. These are freely available at
http://www.libertarian.co.uk
Our postal address is
The Libertarian Alliance
Suite 35
2 Lansdowne Row
Mayfair
London
W1J 6HL
Tel: 07956 472 199
Associated Organisations
The Libertarian International - http://www.libertarian.to - is a
sister organisation to the Libertarian Alliance. Its mission is to
coordinate various initiatives in the defence of individual liberty
throughout the world.
Sean Gabb's personal website - http://www.seangabb.co.uk - contains
about 800,000 words of writings on themes interesting to libertarians
and conservatives
Liberalia - http://www.liberalia.com - maintained
by by LA Executive member Christian Michel, Liberalia publishes
in-depth papers in French and English on libertarianism,
anarcho-capitalism and the free market. It is a prime source of
documentation on these issues for students and scholars.
Libertarian Samizdata - http://www.samizdata.net - works in
association with the Libertarian Alliance and has an ever larger
following. Check it out.